Sometimes I catch a persons name, and especially one I haven't heard for a while and I think "I wonder what happened to them". Of course now with Google and other sourcers of information they can be tracked down if you wish. So it was with real pleasure I read an article online in Mental Health Practice by Prof Michael Traynor. It is called "Constrained by impossible ideals" and it offers (wait for it) a psycho-dynamic perspective on nursings apparent inability to resolve some of its more bedevilling contradictions. Indeed an old friends name (not Michaels...but a reference to Freud) is duly mentioned.
One of his four points to illuminate his argument he refers to is nursings apparent pleasure in "a stance of powerlessness and victimhood". This is evidenced by behaviours that are self defeatting and exhibited in that familiar process we often refer to as "wingeing".He supports this by reference to the Death Drive that Freud saw as part of his Pleasure Principle (not to be confused with the Gary Numan album of the same name), and further more this behaviour provides a degree of pleasure and relief from the conflict and tension that the role possesses.
The author really does have a valid point in his argument that nursing faces in many ways an impossible ideal, and as we know today an ideal that is the benchmark against which all nurses are judged, and publically so. Also it sems quite plausible that a powerless workforce that engages in such behaviour is of course more malleable and convenient to direct (guide, bully,influence.....take your pick)
Sigmund Freud certainly a name from the past in many ways but an interesting theoretical insight none the less
Oh just in case you think this is mere psychobabble then remember the work of Isobel Menzies in the 1960's ,quoted by many in reference to task allocation but predicated on the same underpinnings.
No comments:
Post a Comment